November 10, 2005
Names instead of numbers
Yesterday there were x number of people killled in Iraq. I read it in the papers and online. What were their names? All of them, not just the Americans, not just the Iraqis. Not just the innocents, or the heroes, or the villians. All of them. What were their names?
I wish there was a web site. I wish that instead of publishing the numbers, the news reporters who tally the dead uploaded the names of those people who died to the site. I wish the site took their names (in both Arabic and English), mixed them all up and published them with the dates of their deaths.
I wish the web site was a wiki, so that people could go and find the names of the people they knew who've died, click their names and add information about them. To add information about their families. To allow them to put up a nice picture of the person from last year. To add the date they were born to the date when they died.
People could describe what they were like. How they fed their families. What their hopes and fears were. All of them. Not just the Americans. Not just the Iraqis. Not just the good people. Not just the bad ones. The names of their towns, their churches, their schools. The sports they played, and their favorite books. Who they hated. Who they loved.
Who were their families? Who were their fathers and mothers? Who were their spouses and friends? Who were their sisters and cousins? Brothers and Uncles? Who were their children? Are they dead too? Are they alive? Do these people think their fallen loved one a hero or a villian? Are they nice people or cruel? Defiant? Mourning? Are they protesters? vigilants? Still pursuing the cause? Did they fight too? Will they fight later? Do they hate the people who killed the person they knew? Do they want revenge? Did the person who died want revenge?
I think publishing the names would be better than publishing the numbers. Then those people who died wouldn't just be numbers anymore, they'd be people again.
Then I could go and read about these people. Read their names, and see where they are from, and who they knew. I could find out about them. I could go and see how many of them I know.
I bet I know all of them.
Posted by wcaputo at November 10, 2005 12:21 PMHis name was Robert Paulson.
Posted by: kpd at November 10, 2005 02:20 PMI agree with you. What a powerful means of humanizing the conflict. Once others understood we are dealing with people, not a number, there would be such a greater impact. We may not agree with the "villians", their means and goals, but we could see the similarities.
Unfortuantely, the media will never do this. We are "war" (who is the enemy? "terror"? "Osama"? "Drugs"? or simply the poor and uneducated without any power?) and dehumanizing the "enemy" is the only way to sustain a long term conflict. This initiative must come from the artists since it is there responsibility to make connections we do not normally see or engage us in ways that make us uncomfortable.
Posted by: Carlton at November 10, 2005 03:47 PMWhat is "the media?" Is that something like "the soldier", "the terroist", "the insurgent", "the civilian", "the hero", "the casulty", "the enemy", or "the victim"?
All I know is:
There are people out there who know the names behind the numbers.
There are people out there who know the people behind the names.
There are people out there with the abiltity to provide the web site to bring them together.
I simply hope someday to read the results of their collective efforts.
Posted by: Bill at November 10, 2005 04:06 PMhttp://www.yadvashem.org/wps/portal/IY_HON_Entrance
Posted by: Ksenia at November 10, 2005 05:02 PMOne reason _not_ to report the names immediately is that the families should be contacted first. However, I agree... the deaths should not be anonymous forever.
Posted by: Robert at November 10, 2005 06:16 PMFunny - but I had a taxi-driver once tell me the same thing. Except of course - he said that prior to the wider adoption of the internet, this sort of information could not be published. Now that we have this medium, it could be used as a great way to put a human face to what might otherwise become a part of the monkeysphere -> http://www.pointlesswasteoftime.com/monkeysphere.html
Posted by: Badri at November 17, 2005 02:11 PMBad Links (January 19, 2006)
Visual Studio Team System Jumpstart (January 18, 2006)
Aligining Value (January 17, 2006)
Lisp Again (January 16, 2006)
Getting It Right (January 13, 2006)
Efficiency vs Productivity (January 12, 2006)
Stubbornness (January 10, 2006)
Writing To Annoy Yourself (January 9, 2006)
Due Process In The Workplace (January 5, 2006)
(All Entries...)